Populations was significantly higher under the natural-insect condition than that under the controlled insect condition

These results indicate the effectiveness of insect control in our experiment. In addition, as indicated by the insect damage on weedy parents and transgenenegative plants, significantly higher insect index was also detected in pure planting plots than in the mixed-planting plots of nontransgenic plants with transgenic plants under natural insect. In contrast, the mixed-planting plots with transgenic plants did not show such significant differences in insect index under low insect pressure. All together, these results demonstrate that the differential environment allowed us to analyze the fitness effect of insect-resistance transgenes in weedy rice plants against their nontransgenic counterparts, and that the mixed planting of transgenic plants in a field plot can significantly reduce the ambient insect pressure. In pure planting, transgene-positive crop-weed F4 plants showed significantly greater values of fecundity-related traits, such as the number of panicles and well-filled seeds and the ratio of seed set than their transgene-negative plants under natural insect pressure. Particularly, the number of panicles and filled seeds of transgene-positive F4 plants showed significantly higher values than the weedy rice parents. However, such significant differences between the transgenic plants and nontransgenic plants were not detected in these traits under the low insect pressure. The increased fecundity of transgenic crop-weed F4 plants is most likely brought by the introgression of insect-resistance transgenes that significantly reduced insect attack to the plants. The increased fecundity in the transgenic F4 plants demonstrates that the introgressed insect-resistant transgenes are still effective on controlling rice target herbivores in the advanced generation of crop-weed hybrid populations. This result is consistent with our previous study in which the F2–F3 lineages derived from the crop-weed hybrids with the same transgenic event showed effective control of insect damages to the hybrid lineage NVP-BEZ235 compared with both transgenenegative hybrid lineages and the weedy parents, under a high level of insect pressure. Many previous studies on cropweed and crop-wild hybrid lineages also demonstrated that insect-resistance transgenes can dramatically reduce the target herbivores and increase the fecundity in hybrids and their advanced generation of hybrid populations. These findings are consistent with our results in this study. It seems possible to make a conclusion from the field experimental data of above studies including ours that the introgressed insectresistance transgenes will maintain their strong ability to control herbivores and increase fecundity of transgenic populations derived from crop-weed or crop-wild transgene introgression. The transgenic plants may have a strong ability to compete with their nontransgenic counterparts including nontransgenic hybrid and parental populations. However, it is necessary to point out that in the mixedplanting plots the fecundity traits of the transgene-positive plants did not show significantly increased values, compared to the transgene-negative plants and weedy rice parents under natural insect pressure. This result suggests apparent losses of fitness benefit that should have been brought by the insect-resistance transgenes in mixed planting under natural insect pressure. The similar phenomenon was also observed in a number of studies in which the fitness benefit and cost of insect-resistant GE rice lines and their nonGE parental lines was analyzed under natural and low insect pressure, respectively. Associated with the data of insect index from this study where significantly lower insect pressure was recorded.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.